Email subscribe to LLC blog updates:
Your email:
www.agoda.com

Recent Forum Posts

Recent Comments

Love Is Art That Must Be Practiced – Part III

爱是种艺术,它必须得到实践 – 第三章


MeditationIn previous parts (part I, part II) of this article I discussed the premises for any kind of art (as outlined in the book of Erich Fromm “Art of Loving”). It’s time now to conclude the subject by describing four qualities specific for the art of loving.

First of them is objectivity – ability to see and judge other people independently from our own desires and needs. Of course, it’s natural that we favor people who please us and contempt those who displease us. Moreover – such biased judgment is an almost inevitable stage of any romantic relationship. But the more blind the infatuated person is in the beginning – the deeper will be his/her disappointment when the “fog” dissipates.

And then it’s easier to put the blame for failed illusions on partner than look for the reason in ourselves. Funny enough, some people – after repeating the same scenario of falling in love and getting disappointed a number of times – prefer admitting that they “have lost faith in love” rather than trying to change their own attitude.

Since my blog revolves around the topic of intercultural relationships, it’s appropriate to note that intercultural/interracial dating is by itself a good test of ability to be objective. The way in which people learn, experience and judge other culture (and their own!) reflects the person’s maturity level. As a side note, just as it’s impossible to love someone else without first loving yourself – it is also impossible to truly respect and love a foreign culture/country without respecting your own. Otherwise such “love” is degraded to the level of fetish.

Objective judgment of yourself, your partner and the circumstances of relationship can reveal many obstacles existing on the way to happiness. Here comes into play another quality described by Fromm – faith. He distinguishes between irrational faith and rational faith. The latter – which he sees as the necessary premise for the art of loving – is characterized by healthy belief in positive outcome. Example of rational faith is parent believing in his/her child and helping him/her to grow and realize the potential (without manipulating!)

My readers know very well how many obstacles they have to overcome in order to make their dream come true: long distance, reluctance of parents, fear of unknown, financial difficulties, lengthy legal procedures and so on. I believe that couples which keep faith in their happy future and are faithful to each other deserve to be happy and eventually succeed.

To have faith in yourself and your partner requires courage. Fromm describes courage as “the ability to take risk, the readiness <…> to accept pain and disappointment

To be loved, and to love, need courage, the courage to judge certain values as of ultimate concern – and to take the jump and stake everything on these values.

To spare unnecessary words of how important the courage is for true love, I will put here a link to the famous song “The Rose”.

The last premise of art of loving that Fromm mentions in his book is activity. The accent on active state of mind lies in the fact that Fromm uses the word “loving” instead of “love”. Activity (as opposed to laziness) is expressed in the inner state of awareness, intensive feeling and thinking during all the time that the person is awake.

It is tightly connected to the principle of discipline and concentration discussed in the previous parts.

And like with other qualities, also activity has the special meaning in intercultural relationships. Besides learning each other’s personal traits, lovers need to be always sensitive to cultural differences. Actually, besides being a challenge – dating a person from other culture is blessed with the opportunity to constantly learn new fascinating things.

This post I dedicate to one of my readers. He loves a beautiful Chinese woman. And at some point he faced unpleasant “truth”. It made him to take a second – more objective – look at their relationship. As far as I know he overcame the initial frustration. Right now, if he wants his dreams to come true, he does need a lot of faith and courage.

Learning the art of loving, Crystal Tao

Incoming search terms:

  • Chinese Yoga Awareness And Acceptance

If you liked this article, consider to subscribe to new LoveLoveChina posts by RSS. You can also follow me on Twitter and Facebook.

And most important! I want to invite you to join LoveLoveChina forums where you can read posts on different topics, leave replies and post your own threads.

  • Nick

    Faith… what a wonderful concept.

    I sent a very long email to my angel one time, very much focused around this concept.

    One small quote from that email

    “I promise always to think the best of you and your intentions. If you
    ever say anything that hurts my feelings, I will always believe that
    it was a misunderstanding and that you did not mean to hurt me.”

    I know there are cultural differences and that there are likely to be misunderstandings, and I wanted her to know that I realized that and I was going to do my best to allow for that and always, always believe in her.

    I am forwarding the entire email to you, Crystal, in case you’re curious.

  • Ziccawei

    Nick, are you for real?

    I seriously wonder about foreign guys when they come to China.
    It’s like ‘anything to declare?’, ‘yeah, sure, I don’t need any of this common sense, why don’t you have it?’.

    • Nick

      I assure you, I am quite real. I live in the USA, not China. I sense that you have had some very bad experiences with women, and I am sorry if that is true. Perhaps my experience is not typical, but that approach to our communication and relationship (as shown in that quote from my email) has worked very well.

      It depends on the lady, and the maturity of both people in the relationship. Ivy and I are in our mid 40s. We are both interested in settling down and making the relationship work. We’ve both been in bad relationships before, and we are doing everything within reason to keep things realistic but also optimistic. We know that there will be communication issues and hurt feelings due mainly to cultural differences. This has already happened several times. Our approach always to assume the best of each other has prevented many problems.

      I am a bit old-fashioned, and of European descent. I will hold a door for a lady, any lady, usually. Ivy was actually upset by that one time when I held the car door for my pipa teacher when she was getting into the cab. Ivy thought that it was only something that I did for her (Ivy) because I love her. I do hold doors, her chair, etc. for her because I love her, but there are apparently differences between the Chinese and European concepts of “common courtesy”. She and I discussed it calmly and came to an understanding. She no longer is upset at me for holding the door for other ladies, but I only hold HER chair and help HER (or her mother) with her coat.

      Also, please keep in mind that that email of promises did not come a week after we met. It came several YEARS after we met. By that time, I knew her very well and felt confident in making those promises, which have stood unbroken ever since.

      Yes, I am quite real, Ziccawei. I hope that some day you will find a lady whom you can trust and who inspires that type of love in you so you will understand.

  • China Shark Mike

    Have to go with Z on this one here. You cannot foresee how well you’ll interact with girlfriend before you actually live together, {vacation is not considered living with one another}. Emails are simply words inputted via the computer. I’ve been in more than I’de like to admit romantic relationships here. It’s a massive cultural difference which you fail to see out of desperation for a soulmate. I’ve been seeing Peg the last month and both of us are seriously considering the next level. Having said that she’s stayed over my place 3-4 days at a time as well as I’ve stayed at her place. This is real, we’ve been through some misunderstandings because of trust issues from the past. I just think you’re setting yourself and your girl up for a dissapointment. Dude, I’ve lived here coming up on 2 years now, I understand Chinese mindset yet do not necassarily agrre with it sometimes. You sound like a lovesick puppy yearning for someone to care about him. Funny thing I was that guy in 1994 when I married a Chinese girl for all the wrong reasons. If you have known her for such a long time why aren’t you already married? If I feel the same way in a month I’ll marry my girl, life is too short. Too many foreign guys are so infatuated with Chinese girls that they want to marry the first one that says I love you to them. Get over it, I love you does not mean the same thing in Chinese. Reality can never reach the fantasy in your mind. I dated many Japanese as well as Chinese so I’m speaking from experience and not a subjected myopic viewpoint. Look at the big picture before jumping in with both feet. I personally know quite a few that married Chinese for the wrong reason and are going through marital problems as well as divorce. Hell, I divorced because she left me not I leaving her. She may well marry you yet that is not a promise she’ll stay with you.

    • Nick

      CSM, I understand what you are saying, and I appreciate the honesty and concern, and I appreciate your candid disclosure of your own situations of the past.

      You are correct in that you cannot truly forsee how you will interact without living together, and I am aware of that. Again, I appreciate your concern and your willingness to share your own experiences so candidly for the benefit of others.

      One of the main reasons we’re not married yet is that I am working out some financial obligations here so that we can start on a good solid financial footing. Those financial issues should be resolved in approximately 6 months if my calculations are correct. The other issue is agreeing on where to live. It’s not a matter of “I don’t want to leave my country”, but simply a matter of what makes the most sense when weighing all the factors. We’ve been working this out and will do the rest of the numbers the next time we’re together physically. We both want this to work.

      I do not want to rush into what is supposed to be a life-long commitment. She agrees with me on this and we have agreed to take our time. That does not, however, prevent me from letting her know where I stand and assuring her that I will treat her with respect and trust. (She was seriously abused in her last relationship, so this is an important matter.)

      Also, with making those promises, I now must keep them. This will show her that I take our relationship VERY seriously and that I will do my best to keep those promises. So far, so good. We’ve spent quite a bit of time together and things are working out so far.

      Again, I appreciate your candidness, CSM, and I hope that things work out for you in finding a more permanent relationship if that is what you want. At 44, I think I’ve finally found the lady with whom I will grow old. We’ve been through quite a bit of difficulty, and we’ve weathered it so far quite well.

      I do resent the “lovesick puppy” comment, though. It was only after several years that I made those promises to her. I think we’ve all done the “lovesick puppy” routine once or twice. I passed that a long time ago. I’m just trying to be open and honest about my feelings for her, and I am trying to be true to myself.

      To quote your other post, “Do it because it feels right in your heart and you’ll never go wrong in life.” That is exactly what I am doing. I am giving reassurance to someone I love who has been badly mistreated by someone else. I am promising to be a gentleman (which I am anyway) and promising to treat her like a proper lady. I have a deep respect for the Chinese culture that began in my teen years when I studied Chinese martial arts (Wah-Lum Preying Mantis Kung Fu).

      I share your disdain for those who are simply looking for a “trophy wife” of any sort, be it a “China Doll” or just some other ornamental partner. Marriage is a true partnership, cooperation, and co-existence. The two in the relationship must respect each other and nurture each other.

  • China Shark Mike

    Crystal, sorry for leaving back to back posts. I thought this was pt. II so I just posted without reading through. The articles are insightful and are without a doubt a good depiction of how to maintain a happy cohesive relationship. Problem being is that’s a perfect world in which we do not live in. My girl and I agreed upon 90% compatible as an acceptable level for one another. Must always take into account 10% margin of error due to whatever reason. I went through different phases of relationships here. That being said I’m that much the wiser and more confident that I’ll finally succeed after almost 2 years. Saying your on the same page is not the same as actually being on the same page. Cross cultural relationships are hard as hell even when both are very similiar in tastes and temperent. Don’t buy into the fetish {which I completely acknowledge yet cannot partake in}. I love the culture not just the idea of having a quote unquote China doll. Personally, those kind of characters tick me off. Wait let me marry then bring her to my country where I can show her off to the locals in my hometown. Do it because it feels right in your heart and you’ll never go wrong in life.

  • China Shark Mike

    Nick, sorry if I offended with the lovesick puppy dog comment. I’ve been here coming up on 2 yrs and have seen too many foreigners get nuts over a woman just because they paid them a little notice unlike the western women in thier past. Sounds to me like you are a fellow eggman {yellow on the inside white on the outside}. If that’s the case I think you are one of the good guys. Too many foreigners are just looking for eye candy. In my humble opinion I think you should try to work out some kind of extended vacation to have a real live in experience to see if you could actually be good with one another. Everything in theory or on paper looks good yet many times just not suitable for one another. Just playing devil’s advocate. China Shark will always be the bad guy, whatever. I say what I mean, my actions have always pushed me forward in life. I moved to Shenzhen after 2 months intense emails to move in with my girl and start a new life. Unfortunately, we broke up 3 months later because of we just were not right for one another. If you experience Chinese culture 24/7 you have a better chance at realising what her needs and your needs are. Sacrifice is something you must learn if you want to marry a Chinese woman. Yeah, I miss America big time. My nice big luxury apartment, my own car, my friends, my family, etc. To attain anything in life you must be willing to follow the path less chosen. But the rewards will be tenfold for the persaverence and tenacity. Right now I feel like my life has just started with this new woman. I have nothing and she still wants to be around me all the time. Hell, I have a hard time tolerating myself sometimes. She comes with me to some of my classes, she makes the effort to show me that I’m the most important thing in her life. These might not be the words you want to hear but heed the advice of those more experienced in Chinese culture. Z lives here so I can at least say he’s speaking from actual experience and not some info gleaned from Wikapedia. Life is not about black and white but shades of grey. Life is simple, human beings just complicate it. I’m approaching 50 in two years and the older I get the more I realise the little I actually know. Think that could be wisdom or early onset of senility.

  • Nick

    CSM,

    I understand your point, and I agree that there are many foreigners who are just looking for “eye candy”, as you put it. I am accustomed to sacrifice to achieve things. I have two doctorates in completely unrelated technical fields, including one earned while working full time. I’m no stranger to that kind of effort.

    I am happy that your lady understands that there is more to life than material things. I’m happy for you. My little angel is like that, and it is wonderful. She even sat through an 8 hour lecture that I gave on file system mechanics and forensics one time, even though she barely understood anything I was saying because of the highly technical nature of it. If that’s not love, I don’t know what is. :-)

  • disagree

    You guys are talking in circles. Romantic Love is a bourgeois romanticist idea originating in 18th century england and france. Like so many things, it has been shanzhai’d here in China. The Chinese concept of romantic live is informed by western notions of romanticism combined with Chinese immaturistic idealism. Most everyone feels emotion, that is not in dispute, so what really matters here is pussy-control. Don’t be such a starry-eyed wuss. Girls are stupid, you should know that by now. They admire shiny things and empty words. on the other hand they are not as stupid as you’d think… A BMW and an apartment go a long way with most Chinese girls. It is about station. You are a westerner, and since Chinese culture has been all but eliminated and supplanted by western materialist ideals (be they romantic love, wealth, or otherwise), the ball is in your court. The cultural differences are not as big as you’d think, you just have a misunderstanding as to what the Chinese level of maturity regarding courtship is. Your best friend in this situation is your arrogance, cuz love it or hate it, that is what Chinese “culture” respects and demands.

    • http://www.lovelovechina.com Crystal

      I wish you to be surrounded by the girls that deserve your attitude :cool:

      • disagree

        It’s funny that you would say that. My wife is Chinese – and she’s from sichuan, too! Ahh – you’re from chongqing, sorry… The thing is my wife is well educated, but she grew up on a farm. She knows what it feels like to be hungry. She knows what it means to work hard. She knows that love is not some triviality for the wealthy. Since she is not encumbered by the ideology of spoiled city-girls, she knows that family is the most important thing; she puts her own vanity aside and focuses on her family. I do too. My words may sound harsh, but but the warning is this: In China, men are happy to marry a strongheaded and proud girl when they are young. Once the couple is in their forties, the man realizes that his wife is fat and wrinkly. She has a nasty attitude and is generally a bore to be around, and so he goes around chasing young girls. This is why I criticize romantic idealism. This shit happens every day in the middle kingdom. Also, tell me where I am wrong about the communists annihilating this culture.

  • China Shark Mike

    Damn Disagree you hit it dead on the money. Your right Chinese culture doesn’t exist anymore, western culture bastardized that for sure. My arrogance was my only saving grace in the beginning. I’ve mellowed out quite a bit now, if I break up with my girlfriend there are plenty others that could take her place. Don’t plan on doing that yet have finally accepted that Chinese as a race are emotionally backwards to say the least {men and women}. If you never grow up you never have to take responsibility for your life. Hence why so many men and women aren’t married and approaching the mid thirties. Kind of pathetic even by American standards. Not married and in your thirties means your damaged goods, defect or flaw therefore couldn’t get a husband or wife.

    • Bored in Sydney

      CSM is your reply here sarcasm? Sorry I never expect sarcasm from different cultures although I do from Aussies. But I thought I had read recently comments about how happy you are with your girlfriend. Now she seems to be disposable?

      Damaged Goods? Please. I wish I had waited and resisted the wedding until well into my 30′s. After all, just because we can marry someone who wants to share their life with us does not mean they are the right one for us. Some people are busy doing things like getting a PhD or whatever and never hit the life we expect them to until later on.

      Although I agree that the superficial desires have taken what was Chinese culture and drowned it in a bucket.

  • China Shark Mike

    Sarcasm is my middle name, need a little levity to sometimes lighten the mood. Yes, I’m happy with my girlfriend yet will not go on the the trials and tribulations in the past like with other Chinese girls preceding her. Truth be told we had a big arguement yesterday yet we both decided to talk about it to work out the problem rather than be very Chinese and either grovel or just leave. This is no middle ground on anything in China. All or nothing in relationships here.