Email subscribe to LLC blog updates:
Your email:
www.agoda.com

Recent Forum Posts

Recent Comments

Women’s Health in China: Problems and Controversions

中国女人的健康:问题和争议


Chinese women

Imagine the following ad on Chinese TV: in the beginning a young couple is shown in moonlight, holding hands and kissing while the music plays in background. You, of course, expect it to be the advertisement of something sweet and romantic… but you are going to be disappointed – unless the quick abortion without pain is falling under the category of “romantic” in your dictionary.

Abortion ads are ubiquitous in China. TV programs, newspapers, magazines are full of pictures of smiling girls promoting these operations with special incentives and discounts. If you are a female student, then by showing the student ID card, you can be lucky to get 50% discount on abortion – as one famous poster of Chongqing hospital for women promised. Universities indeed care about their students – and for freshmen Alma Mater has a handbook with lots of useful information on where to make love and how to get rid of its “fruits” afterwards.

Yatour travel agency in which I worked in the past is located not far from the Chongqing Health Center for Women and Children. So I was happy to accompany my good friend Yang Min for regular check-ups in this hospital during the course of her pregnancy. And each time I didn’t stop to wonder how many 18-, 19-, 20-years old girls were waiting in the corridor… but not for pregnancy check-up :sad: .

Widespread abortions is not the only problem of women’s health in China. Unfortunately, Chinese girls have very undesirable preferences in the field of contraception. As the recent survey of China Population Communication Center shows many Chinese women prefer the “morning-after pill” to other forms of contraception.

The usage of this medicine as ongoing contraception has three major drawbacks: 1) serious side effects 2) lack of protection against sexually transmitted diseases, and 3) high rate of failures (unwanted pregnancies) which eventually lead girls to seek for the aforementioned solutions of affordable abortions.

The logical question is: if girl decided to take pills as means of contraception – why would she prefer to use the “morning-after” pill instead of other less harmful hormonal methods?

In order to answer this question, let me give you an example from different situation. One of my former colleagues was a very occasional smoker. During the lunch break he used to smoke a cigarette or two that he was “borrowing” from co-workers. But he never bought cigarettes by himself. One time he was asked why he never bought cigarettes of his own. He explained that he didn’t regard himself as a smoker – since he smoked only in company of other people. But if he would buy cigarettes – then it would mean that he recognized himself as a smoker, and he would feel bad about it.

Something similar is going through some Chinese girls’ heads.
Good Chinese girls shouldn’t have sex! Well… maybe sometimes :roll: But for such kind of “emergencies” there are these special pills. However, if some girl would buy the pills that have to be taken on constant basis – then she is automatically a “bad” girl… slut!

Let’s move to the last problem I want to mention. It is related to a very high proportion of C-sections in China. The growth of C-sections as means of delivery is the worldwide tendency but the reasons are different in various countries. For example, in U.S. it can be explained as self-defense of medical personnel against possible lawsuits (since in some cases it is easier to avoid complications by performing the operation than doing the continuous monitoring during natural delivery).

In developing countries (and China in the past) the main reason for growth of C-sections is the wider availability of medical services to the general population. But how can you explain this phenomenon when almost half of all deliveries are done by the means of surgery (while the level recommended by WHO is no more than 15%)?

The main reason is that medical staff is interested to increase the rate of C-sections. Compared to natural delivery the standard surgical procedures are characterized by more predictable usage of resources (time, staff and drugs) and are financially incentivized.
Marketers know that minimizing losses and avoiding pain is the more powerful “call for action” than promise of gains and pleasure.
And since delivery is naturally associated with fear and pain, doctors don’t find it difficult to persuade young women that C-section is the optimal choice. From talking with my friends and cousins I can attest that many (if not most) Chinese girls are very afraid of pain accompanying the childbirth and will themselves ask for operation without relation to medical indications. And doctors not always will say “No”.

As you can see there are many problems in the field of women’s health in China rooting from controversial social norms and lack of education in this area. I just hope that it won’t take too long to change the situation for better.

Hopeful Crystal Tao

Incoming search terms:

  • morning after pill china
  • morning after pill in china
  • womens health in china
  • misogyny in china
  • chinese women healthcare
  • Chinese morning after how to
  • where to buy morning after pill in china
  • where to buy morning after pill in chinese

If you liked this article, consider to subscribe to new LoveLoveChina posts by RSS. You can also follow me on Twitter and Facebook.

And most important! I want to invite you to join LoveLoveChina forums where you can read posts on different topics, leave replies and post your own threads.

  • j

    Thank you for posting this. You are very brave because these are very controversial topics.

  • Bill

    Aren’t epidurals offered in China??

    • http://www.lovelovechina.com Crystal

      Here is the best answer to your question that I found in one journal:

      In China many women in labor are young primigravidas whose fear of labor pain leads them to request cesarean deliveries. While the rate of cesarean deliveries has reached 50% in many hospitals, less than 1% of women in labor are given neuraxial analgesia. The necessary equipment is seldom available in China and many physicians have misconceptions about the risks associated with neuraxial analgesia, which are low with the ultra-low-dosages used today. However, attitudes have begun to change. Meetings held in China have brought together Chinese physicians and world experts on the various epidural and combined spinal–epidural techniques. Thanks to the information and support provided at these meetings clinical trials were carried out, more than 5000 women benefited from labor analgesia, and publications appeared in Chinese journals. An effective, safe, and cost-effective way to provide analgesia to women in labor may slow the increase in cesarean delivery rates across China and improve women’s health in general.

      • Bill

        Thanks, Crystal.

        My wife has had two children here in the US. When she was pregnant with our first girl she was in Beijing and had some issue which prompted her to go to the hospital maternity ward there. She couldn’t get out of there fast enough. No regard for pain and suffering of the women, and no privacy – people with no business being there just walking through while you’re there in the stirrups.

        A little off topic, but related, in 2000 my wife’s mother had esophageal cancer, for which they did a major surgery to cut out the cancer. She suffered through a week of intense pain as the cuts healed. My wife did manage to buy some western drugs to ease the pain – but it was over almost everyone’s objections, including my mother-in-law’s siblings. The reason? They were afraid of addiction.

        And I’m sure costs are a big issue, though they should be less and less of an issue today with China’s new found wealth.

        Your journal excerpt rings true. And thanks for the new word – primigravida.

        -Bill

        • http://www.lovelovechina.com Crystal

          You are welcome, Bill … I just checked this word in dictionary myself :lol:
          Anyway, here is an excellent post about privacy issues in Chinese hospitals.

  • Ziccawei

    It is totally totally shocking the number of Chinese girls that are happy to use the morning after pill as a regular form of contraception. Chinese guys, for the most part, seem like a total bunch of selfish, idiotic arseholes who practically insist on the girl taking this pill.
    As one guy said to me after taking a girl to a hotel – ‘She can take some medicine, then she won’t have a baby’. When I asked him why he didn’t use a condom he laughed and said ‘Oh, I don’t like to use them’.
    I’m not sure of the exact figure but the number of morning after pills distributed last year runs into tens of millions in China.
    Again, all of this stuff is the result of China’s rapid development, too much, too fast, too soon.
    Read Louis Althusser’s theory on The Ideological State Apparatus – China (and in fact Shanghai) are just perfect models of this theory.

    • http://www.magnoliaarts.com TLB

      Growing up in the 60s “free love” time in the USA, I’m ashamed to say that we young men often had this kind of attitude at that time (“it’s the girl’s responsibility”). I have a sense that young men of today in the West have a more enlightened attitude (i.e., that this responsibility is shared).

      Crystal’s comment about not wanting to regularly go on birth control makes sense from a cultural perspective, and, if true, shows how sometimes our culturally-ingrained habits of thought can lead us toward self-destructive behaviors. I hope that either the young Chinese men step up and take more responsibility, or the young ladies admit that sexuality is not “being a slut”, or both.

      And wow, Ziccawei, Althusser? Crystal, this blog has taken a turn toward the intellectual! :lol: Ziccy, for those not so well-read in late 20th century French Structural Marxism, can you summarize L.A.’s theory in a paragraph or two? (I know, I know, but both he and Marx are dead, so they won’t mind :razz: )

      • Ziccawei

        Haha… Thanks TLB for putting me on the spot.

        I guess I meant that whole thing of LA and ‘hailing’ – also the ISA theory of his.

        Difficult to sum up in typing….

  • http://laowaiink.weebly.com Mark

    A lot of Chinese women choose a C-section because they want to preserve the *ahem* structural integrity of their lower regions. And many times the baby is simply too large for a petite Chinese woman to deliver easily. In my wife’s case, our child was born about a month early and even at that time he was still almost full-size. My wife’s labor and delivery was only a few hours but I am sure that if the baby had been full-term, a C-section would have been necessary. And from what I hear, the recovery from a C-section is a bitch so that whole idea about avoiding the pain comes back to bite them.

  • keius

    My sister in law had her first child in a Chinese hospital. That was 4 years ago. Her husband bribed the doctor $200 US dollars “NOT” to force a C-section on her…….give them a bigger profit incentive to do things right.

  • PL

    I was going to remark on the ‘Too posh to push’ trend here in the UK, then I found this :

    http://www.beestontoday.co.uk/health-news-from-nhs-choices/Too-posh-to-push-mums.6573128.jp

    Which says that this idea is a myth.

    However, Ziccawei fails to point out that there are plenty of British lads who have fairly neanderthal attitudes regarding the wearing of condoms, and a similar lack of care for the consequences of this for young women.

    • http://www.lovelovechina.com Crystal

      Well… maybe another research is needed to clean Chinese women from “too-posh-to-push” tag.
      But the rate of C-sections indeed seems too high to be explained by medical indications only.

      • PL

        I was all prepared to slag off rich mothers here in the UK, Crystal ! Just shows….. :|

        There may well be a “t-p-t-p” issue in China. It could also be something to do with Doctors/Hospitals. But I agree that something is definitely going on. There’s something going on over here, but it’s not entirely clear what yet.

        • PL

          BTW Crystal

          Without wanting to be too much of a pedant in the title when you say ‘controversions’, did you actually mean controversies ?

          • PL

            Ooops ! That should read “…too much of a pedant – in the title…”

            Just shot myself in the foot with English pedantry….. :oops:

          • http://www.lovelovechina.com Crystal

            Yes, you are right – I made a shameful mistake :sad: … and actually realized it the next day.
            But since it is in the title (and thus part of URL) – I decided not to fix it.
            On the other hand, I sometimes fix mistakes in the body of old articles when I find them.

            • http://www.magnoliaarts.com TLB

              Crystal, I found a reference online to an obsolete definition of “controversion” as “controversy” — so see, you’re teaching us Yanks (and maybe even those “legacy users” of English across the pond :cool: ) about our own language… :lol:

            • PL

              Not shameful at all, Crystal.

              Your English, like my wife’s, is amazing. It is my Chinese (lack of) which is shameful.

  • Ziccawei

    I didn’t fail to point it out as this thread is titled ‘Women’s Health in China: Problems and Controversions’.

    That said, and to bear your point in mind, sex education in England is far more advanced and sophisticated than in China. English girls, even if they being rammed bareback by a different guy every night, are aware of the risks.

    Many Chinese girls are not.

    I know it’s probably not a good source, but China Smack ran a story about a girl who had 5 abortions while she was at university. She had the same boyfriend during all this time. It just begs belief. What the fuck was she or her boyfriend thinking? These people are supposed to be an example of China’s elite.

    I don’t know the medical facts but I’m sure that 5 abortions in four years cannot be good for a young woman’s body.

    • PL

      Hey Ziccy :smile:

      I’m not entirely sure you’re right with that statement :

      http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2010/aug/25/sexually-transmitted-infections-hit-record-high

      http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/datablog/2010/aug/25/stds-england-region-gender-ethnicity-statistics

      http://www.guardian.co.uk/education/2010/jul/22/teenage-pregnancy-government-study

      http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2010/sep/20/youngsters-contraception-sex-education

      http://www.guardian.co.uk/tv-and-radio/tvandradioblog/2010/jul/07/sex-education-show-tv

      http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2010/jul/20/sex-young-peopl-race-rape

      Seems to me there’s still a large amount of ignorance surrounding sex here in the UK.

      The point I was trying to make up-thread was that China is not alone in having young people who are risky in their sexual behaviour and slightly ignorant as to its consequences. I may have misread your tone of comment, but it seemed to be saying “Look at these misogynistic Chinese who don’t care about the consequences of their actions, unlike us Western men.”

      In addition, your reply regarding the lack of knowledge of Chinese girls v. British girls regarding sex education, doesn’t entirely stand up to the evidence from the links above. With regards the ChinaSmack piece you mention, will have to find that, but if it is like many CS pieces, they tend to point up the bizarre and stupid. Just out of interest, what were the MOP or whichever site’s netizens’ comments regarding this ? I bet quite a few of them were along the lines of “TMD how stupid, she is SB”.

      BTW just to say that there are plenty of things about Chinese attitudes which I disagree with, I just think that sometimes we have to look at our own societies a bit closer. One of the things I have noticed is that many of the things that pissed me off in China are things that piss me off here in the UK, it’s just that you notice them more when you are outside your own culture so there is a tendency to think “Ah ! That’s a Chinese thing!” rather than “Ah that’s something I hate.”

      • Ziccawei

        PL – I’m not saying British girls or guys don’t get std’s or unwanted pregnancies. Chav culture has taken care of that. But even the dumbest of all chavs is aware that sex without a condom could lead to an infection or pregnancy. They just have this attitude when drunk and stoned of ‘oh well’.

        I would say MANY MANY Chinese young people are unaware of the risks.

        Talk to a group of Chinese people in their 20′s about sex – they talk about it in the same way that young teenagers would in England. And yet they are sexually active.

        This is because traditional Chinese culture is just train-crashing into modern western thinking at such a rate that no-one knows how to deal with it.

        Chinese culture is misogynistic. Women are second class citizens.
        So it’s not difficult to see how a young Chinese guy would not take any responsibility in the use of condoms.

        • PL

          Hi again Ziccawei.

          I don’t entirely disagree with you, honest. I just think the situation here in the UK vis-a-vis sex and sex education is slightly more complicated than you think. There is a definite issue regarding sex education in this country. I agree that there is a high degree of misogyny in China (although I think things may be changing), but I also think we tend to underestimate the degree to which misogyny is alive and well in Britain (you and I are both British, so I will talk about that rather than ‘the West’, as it is a mistake to see ‘the West’ as a homogeneous entity, and I certainly don’t feel qualified to talk about the US or France, Germany, Netherlands etc. etc.). You and I are both middle class and well-travelled, so we tend to be more ‘liberal’ as regards women and the rights of women than many of our peers. There is a tendency for us to generalise our own views and opinions to the rest of our country-people. I think that the reality is more complex than we might realise – for example there is still a significant gender pay gap in Britain, despite years of equal opportunities legislation – and there has been a definite backlash against “women’s rights” in the last 20 years or so, particularly with the rise of ‘New Lad Culture’ and its unfortunate acceptance by many young women. Apparently, attitudes to women in “The City” (ie financial jobs) are particularly Neanderthal.

          Again, please don’t think I am trying to put you down, things are better than for many(if not, most)women in China, but the situation is more complicated and nuanced in Britain than we would, perhaps, like to admit.

          Right, sermon over, back to normal service… :lol:

          • Ziccawei

            I agree with you that England has it’s own inherent misogyny at play within it’s society and culture – but total lack of knowledge in terms of sex education? I don’t buy it. English people are well aware of the risks involved it’s just that – as you said – lad culture, chav culture, etc pushes this all to the back.

            Take a scenario:

            A young guy takes a girl to a hotel and has unprotected sex with her. He then claims that she can take the morning after pill.

            The scene in England would be likely a ‘chavvy-ish’ kind of guy who’d be congratulated by his Stella-drinking mates and told to get some in.

            The scene in China would be likely be ANY Chinese young guy who would look confused and dumbfounded if you told him that the morning after pill is unacceptable.

            The fact is – and I think it IS a fact – is that Chinese young people regard the morning after pill as a perfectly safe and normal form of contraception.

            That is the difference.

            oh, thanks for telling me I’m middle class…. ;-)

  • ahkiwi

    I always thought that “the pill” helped with keeping a woman’s period regular and light in addition to preventing pregnancy. It doesn’t of course prevent STD’s.

    Contraception is (should be) a 2 way street, if a male doesn’t want to use a condom then the female should tell him to get lost (IMHO). That may change in a long term relationship but even there it needs to be give and take.

    I’m not sure why it’s always the female who has to take responsibility for contraception, although looking at most males I can see why. They only seem to be concerned with themselves in the “now” not the other person or the future.

    eh, one day we males might even become civilized … lol wishful thinking.

    • ahkiwi

      Oh, just to add, my sister has had too many C-sections now (3 of them) and has been advised not to get pregnant again. The scar tissue will cause problems I believe.

      • http://www.lovelovechina.com Crystal

        As for Chinese women, one child policy eliminates the “danger” of future complications.

    • SB

      In terms of preventing pregnancy, the pill is nontrivially more effective than condoms (.3% vs 2% with perfect use and 8% vs. 15% with typical use) as well as making periods more regular in most women (it can also have some other positive side effects like reducing acne). If you’re in a monogamous relationship where STDs aren’t a concern and your girlfriend doesn’t have any side-effect issues and isn’t a smoker, it’s probably a better option, though using the pill AND a condom reduces your risk even further. That having been said, this apparently Chinese habit of taking the morning-after pill as a standard method of birth-control is probably the worst of all possible worlds, you get the nasty side-effects of regularly screwing up your body chemistry with big doses of high-hormone pills without getting the greater effectiveness of a proper low-dose oral contraceptive regimen.

  • Jay K.

    “Something similar is going through some Chinese girls’ heads.
    Good Chinese girls shouldn’t have sex! Well… maybe sometimes But for such kind of “emergencies” there are these special pills. However, if some girl would buy the pills that have to be taken on constant basis – then she is automatically a “bad” girl… slut!”

    i love bad girls, oh ya baby!

    on a lighter note, ive often also been really surprised how so many women in china who are sexually active dont take the pill but will prefer the morning after pill also.

    this topic is a good topic

  • China Shark Mike

    I can’t believe I finally read this thread and couldn’t figuire out what the article was about because of your typo Crystal. It just goes to show you that contraversary sounds much more intriguing than conversions. Hence, never bothered to read up till now. I have a friend who is a rather naive Canadian who told me yeah, I finally did it without a condom with his girlfriend. He was so proud of himself and then sudden realization came to me she was unwittedly using the abortion pill. He and his girlfriend had no idea what the pill actually was. So there you go, ignorant westerner and ill informed Chinese woman. He was aghast when I explained that his girlfriend was taking the morning after pill that I think was commercially made available around 10 years or so. Part of the problem stems from abortions being completely acceptable medical procedures, {like getting a routine catscan}. In the west abortions are highly codemned yet practiced as only a last ditch effort. I personally {American} dated one girl who confessed to me that yes, she had 5 abortions from the same boyfriend, {unfortunately in her case she was a slut with no self control}. Abortions do untold damage to the body, maybe even eventually make the women infertile or more prone to cancers later on in life. Reason why these things are accepted are due to female babies being catscanned prior to the
    2nd trimester {still abortable}, general apathy towards a human life. Chinese culture of me me is killing a once beautiful culture. As men we should shoulder 50% of the responsibility

  • sleekgecko

    Your article, perhaps, leaves the impression that abortion is widespread in China, and condoned. My impression is that’s not necessarily true. One Chinese woman I met hated her husband and set about to get an abortion. She was “in the corridor.” However, at the last minute, when her name was called over the loudspeaker, she felt really guilty and left the hospital. Ultimately, she gave birth and raised the baby on her own.

  • hass

    where do i get the after morning pills ? in guangzhou urgent !!!

    • http://www.lovelovechina.com Crystal

      How urgent is it? :roll:

      • hass

        hey crystal do u have any email ? you live in guagzhou and do u have any idea where can i found those pills

        • http://www.lovelovechina.com Crystal

          Go to any pharmacy or sex shop and ask

          “Wo xiang mai shi hou bi yun wan” (我想买事后避孕丸)
          “I want to buy morning after pills”

  • Ravs Singh

    I completely loved your write-up. I am an Indian and could completely relate to the current scenario as far as Cesareans are concerned. The cynic in me says that it’s all business after all.